The Super Bowl Paradox: How Challenger Brands Are Winning Without the $7 Million Ad
For decades, Super Bowl advertising operated on a brutal, winner-take-all principle: either you secured a broadcast spot, or you accepted irrelevance. But as the cost of a 30-second spot has climbed 75% over the last decade to hit $7 million, a massive inefficiency has opened up in the market—one that data-savvy challenger brands are finally exploiting.
While the industry obsesses over the broadcast buy, the real opportunity lies in the data. Streaming has surged to capture nearly half of total TV viewing time, yet it still commands only around 30% of total ad budgets. This disconnect, highlighted by recent Nielsen and eMarketer data, creates a "Super Bowl Paradox" where the most engaged inventory is also the most undervalued. The efficiency gap is real, and it’s wide open.
The math is compelling. In the days leading up to the kickoff and the 48 hours immediately following the final whistle, CPMs drop by 40–60% compared to game-day pricing. Yet, during these windows, viewership for prediction videos, player profiles, highlight packages, and analysis rivals pre-game levels. This is the "Super Bowl Paradox"—a window where brands can achieve near-identical reach to major sponsors at a fraction of the cost, often with significantly higher conversion intent.
The Super Bowl isn't a moment anymore. It is a week-long attention cycle, and the brands winning in 2025 are the ones treating it that way.
Mapping the Week-Long Attention Cycle
Working across challenger brand campaigns throughout last year's playoff season, we watched a pattern emerge that is rewriting the rules of participation. Brands utilizing a sequenced CTV strategy are competing against traditional broadcast buys not just on efficiency, but on measurable conversion.
When attention spreads across multiple days rather than concentrating in one broadcast, the strategy must shift from "blasting" to "layering." This relies on spaced repetition to build memory structures.
It starts roughly a week out. Fans are already deep into Super Bowl content across CTV platforms, but the auction pressure is manageable. This is the ideal time to deploy longer creative units—30 to 45 seconds—that deliver full narrative arcs. You aren't chasing immediate conversion here; you are creating the mental availability that will pay off later.
As the weekend hits, the dynamic changes. The foundation is set, so the creative should shift to shorter, punchier formats. The brain doesn't need the whole story again, just a cue to retrieve what was already encoded. Think of Old Spice’s famous "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like" campaign. You don’t need to re-watch the full monologue to get the joke; a single glimpse of the towel or the horse is enough to instantly unlock the entire narrative. Short-form CTV (6–15 seconds) during the weekend hype utilizes this same psychology, maintaining cost advantages while delivering the high frequency needed to cut through the noise.
Finally, there is the post-game surge. This is perhaps the most undervalued asset in the Super Bowl ecosystem. On Monday and Tuesday, audiences flood back for analysis and highlights, yet most advertisers have already packed up. By layering in retargeting here, utilizing that 40–60% CPM discount, brands reach an audience that is primed to act.
From Brand Play to Growth Channel
The final piece of the puzzle is measurement. Cross-device attribution now allows us to track how these CTV exposures influence behavior across the funnel, flipping the Super Bowl from a pure branding play to a measurable growth channel. In campaigns we’ve run at AI Digital, CTV paired with display retargeting consistently delivers 30–40% higher engagement than display alone.
We saw this play out in real-time last season with a luxury gaming resort in Pennsylvania. By ignoring the broadcast hype and focusing on the surrounding week, we utilized long-form storytelling pre-game, shifted to short-form units during peak playoff traffic, and followed with heavy post-game retargeting. The result wasn't just brand awareness; the campaign delivered a 5:1 ROAS on hotel bookings directly attributed to those CTV exposures.
Similarly, a national creamer brand facing a hyper-saturated plant-based market used this approach to drive trials without a broadcast budget. They deployed high-impact prime-time CTV for awareness, followed by dynamic ads via a retail media network to bridge the gap to in-store purchase. The closed-loop measurement revealed that the campaign drove a 10x ROAS and converted over 15,000 new-to-brand buyers, proving the strategy won net-new market share rather than just recycling existing customers.
The Future is Asynchronous
Streaming continues to consume sports viewership. With ad-supported tiers expanding across Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video, and Peacock, the structural economics of the Super Bowl are shifting under our feet.
Premium reach is no longer locked behind in-game inventory. CTV impressions distributed across the week often deliver a better cost-per-completed-view and stronger downstream engagement than broadcast saturation. The question isn't whether to participate. It’s about aligning with how audiences actually consume and remember content. Brands that grasp the interplay between attention, memory, and measurement will outperform those still chasing a single moment.
[Editor's note: This is a contributed article from AI Digital. Streaming Media accepts vendor bylines based solely on their value to our readers.]
Related Articles
The Super Bowl is a one-of-a-kind live TV event that requires a context-aware approach to measurement — and one that doesn't prize immediate action as the gold standard. It reveals something important for performance marketers: performance is defined not by speed but by outcomes.
20 Jan 2026
As we look toward 2026, the takeaway is not that Super Bowl advertising is getting bigger. It is getting more digital, more flexible, and more strategic. The next phase of growth won't come from adding more ads, but from rethinking how monetization shows up inside the live sports experience. Here are three predictions shaping what comes next.
06 Jan 2026
News that the entire NFL Network was going to Disney World created reverberations throughout the streaming ecosystem, particularly with the pending August 21 launch of ESPN's new D2C service. How is the streaming industry reacting? We went ‘round the horn (with apologies in advance for mixing sports metaphors) with a handful key industry vendors and experts for their initial thoughts, and here's what we heard.
08 Aug 2025