Low-Latency Streaming for Interactive Video
Low latency streaming presently holds much promise for a variety of applications, but it is not quite at a technical level where it has been readily adopted for all streaming applications. “What are the technical and business objections that [are] currently withholding people from really going all the way [with it]?” Mark De Jong, Co-Founder, and Chairman, CDN Alliance, asks Bill Wishon, Chief Product Officer, Phenix Real Time Solutions.
Wishon first provides an anecdote. “I used to work for a guy named Philippe Kahn, an inventor and a serial entrepreneur who very successfully started multiple businesses and sold them. I had the opportunity to have dinner with him once. I asked him, what was it that he did to be serially successful like that, and I'm paraphrasing, but he said: basically, looking for the value in what he's doing, providing value out of his company. And I mention this because if you think of real-time and lowering latencies as something that has value, where are these value points in the market? Is there value in being able to interact with one another in real-time?” Wishon goes on to highlight that while COVID obviously proved the inherent value in being able to interact with people globally over video calls, beyond that, ultra-low latency has the potential to unlock unique and unprecedented experiences for users.
“At Phenix we're delivering video for things like auctions that require real-time,” Wishon says. “We're delivering video for sports and sports gambling like horse racing, enabling people to interact through gambling and gamification that adds additional value on top of just sitting back and watching the content.” He continues to emphasize that while the traffic for low latency live interactive video streaming is still below 50%, “they're starting to become high profile events with high scale. And I think we'll start to see more people adopt it as these use cases become obvious.” For example, he notes the work that Phenix has done with Verizon, with a multi-view application for the Super Bowl and their in-stadium experience.
Jeroen Mol, VP of Innovation, Livery Video, agrees with Wishon. “I think interaction is going to be the driver of low latency video streaming. The question is, how low do you need to go?” Mol says. “But interactive live streams are not there yet. You see them, but you lack the interactive capabilities on top of the live streams that enrich the video. I think that in the near future, you [will] see more sports events or conferences or other life events where interaction is a key element of the viewing experience. And when that happens…that is the moment where I see the global adoption of low latency video…the question is how low?”
“Well, zero – real-time,” says Keith Chow, Senior Product Manager, IP Network Nokia, with a laugh.
Moll says that while there are still many technical challenges to reaching ultra-low latency, Livery Video is working on solving them. “So, if there is packet loss, or if the whole family is streaming Netflix at home while somebody else is watching a live stream, you need to accommodate for that,” he says. “And that is where we see a sweet spot around low latency with interactivity, and then especially interactivity that is structured between three and five seconds...that is where we are aiming for.”
Learn more about Low-Latency Streaming at Streaming Media West 2022.
Watch full-session videos from Streaming Media East 2022.
CDN77's Juraj Kacaba sits down with Tim Siglin to discuss low-latency streaming and the edge in this interview from Streaming Media East 2023.
What makes a stream interactive? What are the elements of interactive streams that audiences respond to most, and create the most engaging lean-forward experiences? Parks Associates' Jennifer Kent, 090 Media's Alex Lindsay, nanocosmos' Oliver Lietz, and LG's Brian Miller explain what makes streams interactive to them and streaming consumers.
videoRx's Robert Reinhardt guides viewers through the key enabling technologies of low-latency streaming, including server ingest and client delivery protocols like WebRTC, NDI, RTMP, and HLS in this presentation from Streaming Media West 2022.
How much streaming reliability and quality are worth trading for ultra-low latency, and when is one at a premium over the others? Amagi's Brian Ring, Dolby,io's David Hassoun, Nomad Technologies' Adam Miller, Paramount's Corey Smith, and Norsk CMO Eric Schumacher-Rasmussen discuss in this panel from Streaming Media West 2022.
What's driving streaming engagement, and where is interactivity for sports fans watching live streams and using streaming apps? And what are the current challenges to delivering interactive sports streaming experiences? Parks Associates' Jennifer Kent and ViewLift's Rick Allen discuss these topics in a panel at Streaming Media West 2022.
What are some of the biggest issues encountered when handling interactive streaming at scale? The widespread increase of highly interactive streaming such as auctions, sports betting, and gaming has put pressure on networks while increasing the need to integrate interactivity into more traditional methods of OTT content delivery.
What are the newest engagement and interactive opportunities for both live in-person and virtual event audiences? Finding ways to bridge the gap between in-person and virtual audiences and create experiences that cater to their specific needs is now essential, according to Beth Norber of Mainstream Media, as audiences have grown more sophisticated and expect high-quality interactive presentations.
The best chunk size for low-latency streaming is dependent on a number of factors based on different use cases, and there is often a need for some compromise and tradeoffs in quality or speed. Nadine Krefetz, Consultant, Reality Software, Contributing Editor, Streaming Media, asks three industry experts what their chunk size preferences are for their requirements.
CNN+ Live Operations Manager Ben Ratner discusses how even "ultra-low latency" complicates hybrid (cloud and on-prem) workflows in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2022.
Andy Howard and Tim Siglin discuss the importance of low latency in video conferencing and how popular video conferencing tools like Zoom, Teams, and WebEx use scalable video encoding to guarantee access and lower latency in this clip from their panel at Streaming Media Connect 2022.
Millicast Chief Revenue Officer Ryan Jespersen discusses how WebRTC reduces streaming latency in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2022.
Barrett-Jackson Auction Company CTO Darcy Lorincz discusses how streaming latency demands drive technology decisions and how to tailor latency to specific projects and cost allocations in this clip from Streaming Media West 2021.
Altman Solon Co-Founder Jonathan Hurd discusses recent survey results indicating the leading trends driving the international sports streaming market in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media West Connect 2021.
Companies and Suppliers Mentioned