Video: Will AV1 Eclipse HEVC?
Watch the full panel discussion from Streaming Media West, The Future of Video Codecs: VP9, HEVC, and AV1, on the Streaming Media Conference Video Portal.
Read the complete transcript of this clip:
Timothy Terriberry: One of the things that I think is really interesting about AV1 as compared to the prior generationsis you get 37% better performance. If you look at where you get those gains, HEVC got most of its gains at high resolutions. Right? Add larger block sizes and larger transforms and all that. This time around, that's not what we're seeing.
So, what we're actually seeing is that those 30% gains are relatively uniform across all bid rates and across all resolutions. And what that means is that you are actually going to be able to start targeting a lot more of the world with these kinds of improvements. So, you start looking at places like Africa that don't have the greatest infrastructure where you can save 30% right there, that starts to make a really big difference.
So, I think AV1 is actually going to be able to target a much broader set of use cases than HEVC was enabling.
David Sayed: Do you think the HEVC is going to stand still? In other words, are there more optimizations that are available in the HEVC world?
Timothy Terriberry: This is generally true with any codec: the performance you get out of it when the standard is frozen is not going to be the performance you get out of it five years later.
David Sayed: We saw that with H264.
Timothy Terriberry: Right. And we're going to see that again with AV1. So, I don't think any of these codecs are going to stand still. We continually get smarter about how we make encoder decisions, and I think there are probably plenty of people in this room who are working on those exact problems.
Tarek Amara: The reason I also believe AV1 will be probably more successful is because this time, there are a lot more companies around it. Chip manufacturers are really supporting it. They were very present during the spec design. Lots of commonalities with VP9, which makes time to market a lot faster. And it's royalty-free. So, why would someone not go for something free and better? Even by 5%? Even if it is equal to HEVC? And I think that we will see AV1 deployed a lot faster than lots of people believe.
That doesn't mean HEVC is going to die. It looks like the broadcast market is more of an MPEG-related standard industry, where you see all the TVs support HEVC, and lots of sets of boxes with HEVC. So, all the devices that are for traditional TV broadcast are HEVC-capable today. So, probably that's the market that will be covered with HEVC, but as soon as AV1 becomes mature, we'll have browser support, even Twitch is part of the development, and we added a feature, actually, to even improve our latency compared to HEVC and VP9. Probably within the year, we'll start seeing streams being generated.
FFmpeg 4.0 gives many video engineers their first chance to test the new AV1 codec against H.264, HEVC, and VP9. The results? In our tests, quality was impressive, but glacially slow encoding times make AV1 a non-starter for most publishers until hardware acceleration becomes available.
Streaming Learning Center's Jan Ozer looks at the advantages and disadvantages of encoding directly to multiple social platforms in this clip from Live Streaming Summit at Streaming Media East 2018.
Today the Alliance for Open Media froze the AV1 bitstream and released an unoptimized software encoder and decoder; AV1 decode should arrive in several browsers and some content from member companies over the next few months, with hardware implementations in about a year.
Bitmovin's Stefan Lederer and Twitch's Tarek Amara discuss the changing market dynamics of HEVC in the current codec climate.
Netflix and YouTube could start using AV1 as soon as early 2018, while hardware implementations will take much longer.
Frost & Sullivan analyst Avni Rambhia assesses the key factors content owners face today in determining whether to stick with AVC or move to HEVC.
Frost & Sullivan analyst Avni Rambhia identifies the key inhibiting factors that are impeding the widespread migration from AVC to HEVC.
Frost & Sullivan analyst Avni Rambhia explores the "three 'Rs'" of HEVC adoption: Revenue, Resolution, and thRoughput.
Should you be delivering HEVC? It depends on what you're delivering and who you're trying to reach. Frost & Sullivan analyst Avni Rambhia breaks down the key issues of sticking with AVC vs. migrating to HEVC in this clip from Streaming Media East 2016.
Companies and Suppliers Mentioned