CNN's Ben Ratner Talks Cloud and REMI Production at Streaming Media East 2022
Tim Siglin: Welcome back to Sreaming Media East 2022 here in Boston at the lovely Westin Copley. Weather's much nicer or outside today than it was when I flew in on Sunday. Ben, you're based in New York. Is that right?
Ben Ratner: Right outta New York City.
Tim Siglin: Okay. And you're with CNN.
Ben Ratner: Yes.
Tim Siglin: And what is your focus there?
Ben Ratner: I'm a live operations manager, so I'm basically working on cloud live production for a lot of our digital shows.
Tim Siglin: Okay. And you were on a panel that we did a while back about hybrid workflows. Is hybrid still part of the mix of what you're doing?
Ben Ratner: On CNN Digital and the specific things I'm working on, we're 100% cloud now. We had a hurricane and a snowstorm that knocked out our on-prem computers at two people's houses. So we ultimately decided it's time to be 100% cloud. And we're using cloud not only because it's really useful for what we need to do and all the people working remotely, but because we couldn't necessarily get computers to replace those computers. And it's kind of helping us find are there other places in the organization where we might be able to use some of this technology.
Tim Siglin: So, REMI for the win, essentially, at this point.
Ben Ratner: We're still very much grounded in traditional on-prem tech, but there's a lot of benefits to REMI that I think we're gonna be able to take even more advantage of.
Tim Siglin: Okay. Very good. So what did you speak on here at the show?
Ben Ratner: Cloud production and hybrid production.
Tim Siglin: Very good. And how do you define hybrid?
Ben Ratner: A lot of the tools that we use in the cloud are software that you can use on-prem. We were using vMix on those on-prem hurricane disaster computers. And then we just moved it to the cloud. So I think it's the right tool for the right job. There are certainly things where it's easy to work in the cloud. Just this morning, for call contribution, we used WebRTC-based tools, but there are a lot of banks, government organizations and other high-security situations that just don't let you use WebRTC. So we were able to spin up just in two seconds or two minutes a computer that had WebEx running, and we were able to make that work and just had to switch out some NDI connections and call it a day. So that's something that we couldn't have done on-prem 'cause I would've had to find another computer, boot it up, download NDI tools, all that fun stuff.
Tim Siglin: I remember back when I was installing video conferencing systems for government organizations, initially the thought was just to talk amongst themselves. It turned out it was actually a really good contribution tool as well.
Ben Ratner: Sometimes you just can't beat Zoom or WebEx or some of these services in efficiency on their end. There's a lot of downsides to using them. A lot of quality issues. They've gotten very, very good, to be clear, and we would not be where we were broadcasting--especially during COVID--without them. But there are a lot of things where I would rather have control. There's software that gives me the ability to change their webcam, change their resolution, change their color balance, look at their actual data connection, all that stuff. So I would prefer better solutions, but ultimately we need to get the show on the air and the guest on the air. And if the guest needs us to do it this way, we can accommodate.
Tim Siglin: And I think to a certain extent the viewers have given us latitude over the last two and a half, three years. We understand that people may be coming us on a big show from their home. And so we sort of go, "Okay, that person's at home. If the connection's not so good or the quality's not so good, maybe that's okay." But as you say, ultimately, if we're gonna carry that forward with workflows post-pandemic, we need to keep the quality up to the broadcast level.
Ben Ratner: Honestly, I think that broadcast in general or audiences in general--let's not blame the broadcasters; let's blame the audiences--have tolerated it too much and don't care enough. I think they should have a higher expectation for very good audio quality, very good video quality, very good internet. So I'd like to see across the industry a bigger focus on that. Obviously, it depends on the kind of budget you have. But sometimes a cellphone is better than a laptop. With all due respect to my favorite kind of computer, Apple, they're not known for their webcams. . So the rear camera on your smartphone is gonna be better than the one on your MacBook a lot of the time.
Tim Siglin: To show people what he means. It's a tiny little camera right up here.
Ben Ratner: If you wanna look like you're broadcasting through a potato, use Apple.
Tim Siglin: Versus this.
Ben Ratner: It's just better. The old trope used to be, "Hey, you wanna be wired, you wanna be ethernet." I will very often now be happier with the cellphone signal. That's gonna be pretty good, if not great.
Tim Siglin: On 4g LTE or 5G.
Ben Ratner: Not on, like, 2G.
Tim Siglin: Exactly. Well, Ben, thank you very much for your time and always good to have you and we'll be right back with our next guest.
Some streaming pros say cloud production has made 5-10 years of progress in the two years since the pandemic shook live production to its core, but when will cloud offer the sort of no-latency communication, preview, and replay producers expect and rely on in on-prem workflows? And will it require a paradigm shift in the way producers think about hardware purchases and usage? Live X's Corey Behnke, CNN's Ben Ratner, LiveU's Mike Savello, and Signiant's Jon Finegold discuss the challenges of cloud migration and the current state of cloud in this clip from Streaming Media East 2022.
Brightcove VP of Research discusses the benefits of Brightcove's context-aware encoding and how the renditions it provides differ from the content-aware encoding provided by other vendors in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
id3as' Dom Robinson and Help Me Stream's Tim Siglin discuss the latest Greening of Streaming developments--including taking the conservation case to Parliament--in this interview from Streaming Media East 2022.
Everything streaming is moving to the cloud, right? Not so fast. Where you keep your content and do your work depends on your own particular circumstances. And on-prem is by no means dead.
Streaming Video Alliance's Jason Thibeault and Streaming Media's Tim Siglin discuss the maturation of the streaming industry, the Greening of Streaming, Women in Streaming Media, and the growth of the SVA over the last 2 years in this interview from Streaming Media East 2022.
Red5 Pro CEO Chris Allen discusses the growing market for ultra-low latency, interactive streaming in applications like auctions, betting, and video conferencing and a multi-cloud approach to delivering it in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
kweliTV Founder DeShuna Spencer discusses how the OTT channel curates affirming stories for the global African diaspora rather than focusing on Black trauma like more mainstream services in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
LiveU VP of Sales discusses how LiveU is enabling the evolving trend toward multicam mobile, REMI, and cloud production using bonding-based workflows in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
EZDRM COO and Co-Founder Olga Kornienko discusses the value of DRM for large-scale live events and the fail-safe benefits of a multi-cloud DRM-as-a-service approach in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
Panopto Chief Evangelist Chris Knowlton discusses the advantages of making searchable training content available on-demand to reinforce what students learn in a live presentation in this interview with Streaming Media's Tim Siglin at Streaming Media East 2022.
Streaming Media's Tim Siglin and Bulldog DM's John Petrocelli discuss how tentpole live streaming events have changed over the last three years for the streaming pros who deliver them, the audiences that engage with them, and the brands that invest in them in this interview from Streaming Media East 2022.
Uncle Toad's Chris Steblay discusses discusses how SRT (Secure Reliable Transport) has enabled Uncle Toad and other small broadcasters to move into REMI production and reduce on-site crew and other production expenses in this clip from Streaming Media Connect 2022.
Live X Co-Founder Corey Benhke and NHL Director of Broadcast Engineering Taishon Black discuss how vMix--a tool not originally designed for use in cloud production--and Blackbird have become instrumental in their cloud and remote production workflows.
Gigcasters' Casey Charvet discusses how Gigcasters and the agencies they work with have embraced remote production and virtual and hybrid events--first out of necessity with the challenges of the pandemic, then recognizing the new possibilities and opportunities they offer.