Video: Can Cloud Encoding Deliver the Same Quality as Hardware-Based?
Watch Sean Longworth's full presentation from Streaming Media East, The 5 Myths of Cloud-Based Encoding, on the Streaming Media Conference Video Portal.
Read the complete transcript of this clip:
Sean Longworth: Is it true that quality is not as good in the Cloud as it is in a hardware-based encoder? The answer to that question is: It depends. It's not necessarily true or false. It depends on what kind of software you use. The truth of the matter is the high majority of encoding software built today was built with a fixed hardware mindset. It was built with the assumption that it's going to go on appliance or in some type of fixed mode within the Cloud. If you're an engineering team or an operations team and you are focusing on building a highly efficient encoder that has a controlled environment like an appliance, the majority of your innovation and your engineering focus is going to be on trying to make that machine work as efficiently as possible. You're trying to see how much encoding you can squeeze out of a single GPU or a set of GPUs or a CPU. You really focus on that. That's the majority of the software that's out there today.
If you take that software that is highly optimized for a specific environment and you pour it and put it into the Cloud, it's not going to operate as well. I think that's what most people's experience is with Cloud encoding: they've gotten in situations like that and they've compared it to the hardware encoding, and it's just not as good. Naturally, it's not going to work as well if you do that, but not all software stacks are created equally.
Bitmovin's been around for seven years. We've never had an appliance. We've always done Cloud-based encoding. We've always thought about encoding from a Cloud perspective. Our innovation and our engineering and our focus has not been around how can we optimize the codec of 10% more for this particular GPU and really get the best out of it. Our innovation and what we've always done is thinking about how we can leverage the Cloud more efficiently in order to drive better performance. Specifically, how can we take files and split them up into the appropriate amount of segments and run them off of a variety of resources and then stitch them back together in the most efficient way possible that drives quality? That's just a different track for an engineering team than an appliance team.
Our software, if you took the software that we design and how it works and you put it on an appliance, it would work significantly worse, because we designed all of our engineering and engineering about the ability to use the Cloud. Whether or not something performs better or worse in the Cloud depends on the software and how it was written and how it was architected.
Tektronix Application Engineer Andrew Scott discusses the value of QC tools for live streaming in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media West 2018.
04 Mar 2019
Tektronix Application Engineer Andrew Scott discusses automated live stream monitoring tools for delivery engineering and operations in this clip from Streaming Media West 2019.
25 Feb 2019
Tektronix Video Product Manager Dan Murray identifies the eight essential elements of live stream monitoring in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
23 Aug 2018
Tektronix Video Product Manager outlines the efficiency gains of cloud-based streaming and raises the question of how those advantages enhance video quality in this clip from his presentation at Streaming Media East.
16 Aug 2018
Yorktel's Joe Arena makes the case for on-prem encoding, storage, and management when choosing an enterprise video platform, and having a strong support model in place.
12 Oct 2016