Evaluation Crowns FFmpeg the King of the H.264 Encoders
Want to know what to encode with for great H.264 files? Robert Reinhardt, founder of VideoRx.com, is happy to tell you. One minute into his recent Streaming Media West presentation on how to evaluate H.264 encoders he gave the big reveal: FFmpeg is the best choice around.
"I'll give you the conclusion, which is you can pretty much accomplish the best encoding with FFmpeg and x264, right? There is no way to get around the fact that Sorenson and Telestream and Harmonic or whoever decides to license x264, well, we all have access to those same parameters in FFmpeg. It's the same exact codec," Reinhardt said.
FFmpeg is a great choice for the budget-conscious because it's a free download. But, Reinhardt cautions, that doesn't mean there's no cost.
"The adage 'You get what you pay for' doesn't even really apply anymore given that something like FFmpeg as a tool doesn't cost you anything," Reinhardt said. "Now, we all know, I hope, the difference between price versus cost, right? The price tag of FFmpeg is zero, but what is the cost of using FFmpeg? You need someone who knows how to use a command line utility, knows how to integrate it with your workflow, and is comfortable with that. I'm a geek; I have no problem setting up scripts that are going to automate FFmpeg to fit into a workflow just like a commercial product."
For more on choosing a strong H.264 video encoder, watch the full talk below and download Reinhardt's presentation.
HOW TO: Evaluating Your H.264 Encoder
Not all video encoders are created equal. In this session, the real-world video output of top commercial H.264 encoders are compared, including Telestream Episode, Harmonic ProMedia Carbon, Sorenson Squeeze, and Adobe Media Encoder, as well as those available in the open source community such as FFmpeg and x264. Live streaming hardware and output are also compared. Learn what features you should have available in an encoding tool before you invest your organization’s budget to the effort.
Speaker: Robert Reinhardt, Founder, videoRx.com
Anyone who does performance or benchmark testing, please take a look: The six commands in this article help with essential tasks that crop up in any studio or encoding facility.
With just a few beginner-level scripts, you can encode and package multiple filds to HLS and DASH output using open source tools.
AV1 delivers equivalent quality to HEVC, but with a lower data rate. For now, though, it's slow. A five-second clip took 23 hours and 46 minutes to encode.
Reaching viewers on desktops, notebooks, phones, tablets, and set-top boxes all starts with the same step: Encoding video into H.264.
It's time for an H.264 tune-up. Lean how choose the right encoding tool and optimize H.264 encodes for ideal quality and device compatibility.
Today's video encoders are mostly similar and mostly good, said Robert Reinhardt at Streaming Media East. Still, there are a few features to seek out.
At the Streaming Media East conference, Robert Reinhardt of VideoRX says that MPEG DASH's unified vision is still years away.
Companies and Suppliers Mentioned